Monday, December 21, 2015

Why It's Okay for Hermione to Be Black

Jamie Parker, Noma Dumezweni and Paul Thornley will appear as Harry, Hermione, and Ron in J.K. Rowling's new play, Harry Potter and the Cursed Child.

Once again, an unconventional casting choice has social media in an uproar. Black actress Noma Dumezwini has been cast as Hermione Granger in J.K. Rowling's upcoming play Harry Potter and the Cursed Child, and Twitter and Facebook are blowing up with objections from people who "aren't racist, but . . ." 

In the books, each of the trio has certain defining characteristics. Harry has messy hair and green eyes. The hair is like his father's, but the eyes are his mother's. Ron is a red-head, which immediately identifies him as a Weasley. And Hermione has frizzy hair and buck teeth. These less-than-conventionally-beautiful features allow Ron to overlook her for years, until she appears at the Yule Ball with magically straightened hair and teeth and takes his breath away. None of this precludes Hermione being black.  In fact, in some ways Dumezwini is more accurate to the description in the books than the conventionally lovely Emma Watson. Rowling herself supports the casting and acknowledges that Hermione's race was never an issue.



So why do people get so focused on the physical characteristics of a character? I see this in my students all the time. When I ask them to describe a character I get a lot of information about what the character looks like and what the character does. It's much harder to draw out information about who the character is. This seems to be a rather sad indictment on our society that we are so focused on outward appearance and so little focused on personality, character, and values.

There are times, however, when physical appearance is important. I was a fairly outspoken opponent of the casting of Jennifer Lawrence as Katniss in the Hunger Games franchise. Although Jennifer Lawrence is a brilliant actress, her casting robbed the movie of the poignancy of the books. First, Katniss was 16 when she volunteered to replace her sister Prim as tribute in the games. The casting of young adult Lawrence masked the horror of the fact that the capital was throwing children into the arena to fight each other to the death. Additionally, in the book, Katniss, Gale, and others from the coal-mining District 12 are described as olive-skinned, dark haired, and gray-eyed, while Peeta and others from the business sector are blonde. The movie completely misses the fact that the books speak strongly to the issue of racism.

So is appearance important when casting movies or plays based on books? Absolutely. Some characters wouldn't be who they are without certain physical features, and some works lose their effect when characters are miscast physically. But is appearance the most important thing? Absolutely not. Jennifer Lawrence may not look like Katniss, but she perfectly embodies Katniss, and when she screams, "I volunteer as tribute," I almost forgive her for being too old and too white. It remains to be seen whether Noma Dumezwini can embody Hermione, but I wish I could be in London to find out.






Monday, October 12, 2015

Why AR?

Friday will be the end of our first quarter of school.  With this milestone comes a lot of frantic scrambling. Students who have been lackadaisical up to this point power through previously overlooked makeup work and beg teachers for extra credit to raise their grade to a level that will be acceptable to either their parents or themselves.  Teachers burn the midnight oil wrapping up neglected grading and entering everything into the gradebook.  But nowhere is this phenomenon more evident than in the area of AR points.

For the uninformed, AR is short for Accelerated Reader.  Students read books of their choosing and then take simple quizzes in order to confirm that the book was, in fact, read.  They are awarded points based on the length and complexity of the book and the number of questions answered correctly.  In our junior and senior high school, accumulating a required amount of points accounts for 20% of the final grade for reading (junior high) or English (high school) class.

Some students (and parents) dislike the AR requirement.  They argue that if an individual doesn't like to read and/or isn't good at it he or she shouldn't be forced to do it.  Life is full of things we dislike.  I personally loathe math and am hopelessly inept at anything that involves numbers.  However, I was not excused from doing math in school and have often been grateful for that as an adult.  While my math skills are still lacking, I have garnered enough knowledge to muddle through the applications that I have to utilize as a human being in modern society and a teacher.

Surely no one will argue that reading isn't essential to a productive and successful life in our culture.  Adults read every day, even if they don't realize it.  Not surprisingly, the best way to get better at reading, as is true of almost anything, is to read.  Moreover, in addition to reading being necessary on a purely pragmatic level, it is also valuable on a social level.  Several recent articles have cited research that students who read fiction are more empathetic, more tolerant, and more able to see things from another's point of view.  Reading allows them to get inside the heads of people from different cultures and different lifestyles and to see things from a perspective other than their own.

Since the name of my class is reading, students surely have to expect that they will be required to do a certain amount of reading.  80% of their grade in my class is based on reading things that I have chosen and then analyzing and evaluating those works, usually in writing.  For the other 20% of their grade, they get to read whatever they want, and they don't have to analyze, evaluate or write about it; they just have to answer a few simple questions to prove they have actually read it.  Personally, I think that sounds like a pretty good deal.






Friday, June 26, 2015

What If We Actually Did What Jesus Would Do?

In 1896, Charles Sheldon wrote the story In His Steps, in which Pastor Henry Maxwell challenged his congregation to pledge for one year to do nothing without first asking what Jesus would do if he were in their situation faced with their choices.  Moreover, they were then to follow in his footsteps as best they knew how, regardless of the consequences.  Approximately 100 years later, this message was pirated by the Christian marketing machine and emblazoned on mugs, t-shirts, and of course, bracelets.  While much time was spent arguing over what Jesus would do, I'm not sure many ever got around to the second part of the challenge. For those who did, their convictions were too often put away with their bracelets when the novelty wore off.  In recent days, however, I once again find myself wondering, what would Jesus do?

How would Jesus respond to the shooting at the Emmanuel A.M.E. Church and the subsequent discussion about race relations?  Jesus loved all people and treated them equally, even those most of his peers would have considered inferior.  He taught that we should love others as ourselves and treat them the way we would want to be treated. Many today decry political correctness, but if political correctness means putting the feelings of others ahead of your own, I believe Jesus would choose to be politically correct.  I hear Christians defending their right to celebrate their heritage by displaying a confederate flag, but I don't believe Jesus would do something that caused pain to others, regardless of his perceived "rights."  For Jesus, love for others always came first.

But what would that love for others look like in light of the recent Supreme Court ruling on same-sex marriage?  Some say we should love the sinner but hate the sin.  Interestingly, while I often hear that, I can't seem to find it in the Bible.  In fact, Jesus didn't devote a lot of energy toward hate of any sort.  The only time he even even behaved harshly was toward the religious leaders who were so busy pointing out every one else's sin they couldn't see their own. It's so much easier to wage war against the sins that don't plague us than it is to bare our souls and admit to our own faults, but the only sin the Bible tells us to mourn is our own.  Given the choice between loving the sinner and hating the sin, I believe Jesus would focus on loving the sinner.

II wonder what our country look like if Christians actually accepted Pastor Henry Maxwell's challenge to do what Jesus would do if he were in our situation faced with our choices.  What if we loved others unconditionally, even those who look and behave differently than ourselves, and put their needs ahead of our own?  What if we each focused on dealing with the sin in our own life rather than denouncing the sin of others?  What if we actually did what Jesus would do?