Monday, December 21, 2015

Why It's Okay for Hermione to Be Black

Jamie Parker, Noma Dumezweni and Paul Thornley will appear as Harry, Hermione, and Ron in J.K. Rowling's new play, Harry Potter and the Cursed Child.

Once again, an unconventional casting choice has social media in an uproar. Black actress Noma Dumezwini has been cast as Hermione Granger in J.K. Rowling's upcoming play Harry Potter and the Cursed Child, and Twitter and Facebook are blowing up with objections from people who "aren't racist, but . . ." 

In the books, each of the trio has certain defining characteristics. Harry has messy hair and green eyes. The hair is like his father's, but the eyes are his mother's. Ron is a red-head, which immediately identifies him as a Weasley. And Hermione has frizzy hair and buck teeth. These less-than-conventionally-beautiful features allow Ron to overlook her for years, until she appears at the Yule Ball with magically straightened hair and teeth and takes his breath away. None of this precludes Hermione being black.  In fact, in some ways Dumezwini is more accurate to the description in the books than the conventionally lovely Emma Watson. Rowling herself supports the casting and acknowledges that Hermione's race was never an issue.



So why do people get so focused on the physical characteristics of a character? I see this in my students all the time. When I ask them to describe a character I get a lot of information about what the character looks like and what the character does. It's much harder to draw out information about who the character is. This seems to be a rather sad indictment on our society that we are so focused on outward appearance and so little focused on personality, character, and values.

There are times, however, when physical appearance is important. I was a fairly outspoken opponent of the casting of Jennifer Lawrence as Katniss in the Hunger Games franchise. Although Jennifer Lawrence is a brilliant actress, her casting robbed the movie of the poignancy of the books. First, Katniss was 16 when she volunteered to replace her sister Prim as tribute in the games. The casting of young adult Lawrence masked the horror of the fact that the capital was throwing children into the arena to fight each other to the death. Additionally, in the book, Katniss, Gale, and others from the coal-mining District 12 are described as olive-skinned, dark haired, and gray-eyed, while Peeta and others from the business sector are blonde. The movie completely misses the fact that the books speak strongly to the issue of racism.

So is appearance important when casting movies or plays based on books? Absolutely. Some characters wouldn't be who they are without certain physical features, and some works lose their effect when characters are miscast physically. But is appearance the most important thing? Absolutely not. Jennifer Lawrence may not look like Katniss, but she perfectly embodies Katniss, and when she screams, "I volunteer as tribute," I almost forgive her for being too old and too white. It remains to be seen whether Noma Dumezwini can embody Hermione, but I wish I could be in London to find out.






No comments:

Post a Comment